How can I know that the compost I buy is okay to use?
Compost has been in the news, and not all the press is good. There are concerns about invasive worms, PFAS, and other potential contaminants. You might find yourself wondering: How can I know that the compost I buy is okay? A wise consumer knows what to look for and what questions to ask. We'll arm you with information based on science and outline all the benefits we collectively share when we keep food scraps out of landfills and in compost systems - and use compost in our gardens and yards.
Appreciate this content? Consider making a donation to support our commitment to creating free educational resources!
Learn more about your concerns & understand what questions to ask to ensure you're buying compost you can feel good about using.
Invasive Jumping Worms
Invasive jumping worms, also known as snake worms, are not native to North America, they were introduced from Asia. These worms are a problem in soils because they are highly invasive. They multiply quickly, out-competing other soil organisms, and create a range of negative impacts on soil quality, plant growth, and ecosystem health.
One of the key characteristics of invasive jumping worms is that they are very active and can move quickly through soil. They also have a unique behavior where they wiggle and thrash around when disturbed, making them difficult to handle.
Jumping worms alter the physical and chemical properties of soil. They consume organic matter more rapidly than other earthworms, leaving behind a granular material that plants can’t grow in. This activity negatively impacts soil quality, fertility, and the health and growth of plants and other soil organisms.
There are a few characteristics that can help identify invasive jumping worms:
Movement: Invasive jumping worms are very active and move quickly through soil. When disturbed, they may wriggle and thrash around in a way that is different from other earthworms.
Appearance: These worms have a distinctive appearance, with a smooth, shiny, grayish-brown or reddish-brown body. The lighter-colored collar (clitellum) is flush with the rest of its body and goes all the way around the worm
Castings: Another way to identify invasive jumping worms is by their castings or the soil they leave behind after feeding. The castings of jumping worms are distinctive, with a grainy, coffee-ground-like texture.
If you suspect that you have invasive jumping worms on your property, it's important to correctly identify them before taking any action. You can contact your local university extension office or Department of Agriculture for assistance with identification and management recommendations.
As a purchaser of compost
It’s important to understand that there are different places between a compost facility and your yard where jumping worms might be introduced. We’ve provided some questions that you can ask before purchasing, to feel more confident in the product you’re bringing home.
Questions to ask a compost facility:
-
Knowing that the facility is aware of jumping worms and has a plan in place for mitigating their presence is an important first step. Here are the best practices that we recommend composters follow. Understanding these at a high level will help you understand if the compost facility is doing a good job.
-
State-certified compost facilities are required to follow regulations and best management practices which include minimum temperature requirements that are helpful in controlling the threat of jumping worms.
Non-certified facilities may also reach these higher temperatures and have their own plan for protecting against jumping worms, but it’s not a state-mandated requirement, so it’s good to ask.
-
Jumping worms have spread to every corner of Vermont. It’s likely that you know someone who has them in their garden, mulch, or on the edge of their lawn. This means that there’s a good chance that leaves and yard trimmings used to make compost contain jumping worms or their eggs cases (cocoons).
To help ensure that the worms don’t make it to the finished compost, compost facilities must:
Ensure physical separation of incoming materials and composting materials
Use separate equipment or extensive cleaning procedures between managing these different materials
You can do your part to minimize spread by checking your own leaves and yard trimmings for signs of jumping worms. If you already have them - don’t take them off your property.
Questions to ask your landscaper
-
Knowing that your landscaper is aware of jumping worms and has a plan in place for mitigating their presence is an important first step. Here are the best practices that we recommend landscapers follow. Understanding these at a high level will help you understand if they’re doing a good job.
-
Your landscaper should know if ALL of the places where they source materials are also following best practices for managing jumping worms.
-
It’s important that landscapers are ensuring that clean (worm-free) material is not reinfected either by other material that has jumping worms or by storing it in a place where jumping worms can get into their piles of soil and/or mulch.
-
Again - knowledge is key! Knowing that steps are being taken to identify and remove jumping worms is the most important thing anyone can do. Also - bare-root plants are less likely to come with jumping worms, so if you have a choice - request bare-root over potted plants.
-
Even if your landscaper is taking every precaution with their materials, they may well be providing services to properties infected with jumping worms. Although cleaning tools and equipment between customers may pose logistical challenges, this is the only real way to ensure that jumping worms or cocoons are not transferred from one site to the next.
Questions to ask your garden center
-
Garden centers and plant nurseries are highly susceptible to the spread of jumping worms due to the wide variety of potted materials, bedded plants, mulches, soils, and composts, typically all imported from other sources and co-located within the same facility. Once discovered, some things can be done to reduce spread, but not all facilities have adequate space, hardened surfaces, or resources required to control jumping worm populations.
-
Garden centers should have regular conversations with the suppliers of all of their products, including bulk products, asking them about their own jumping worm management programs to ensure the decreased likelihood of spread.
-
One of the biggest challenges with identifying a jumping worm problem is that the worms are not always visible. Identification is extremely difficult until the worms reach the juvenile or adult stage in late spring and summer. Once they have reached maturity and are mobile, it is much easier to see them. Garden center operators should schedule regular inspections of the areas most prone to harboring worms - below or within potted plants kept on the ground, in or around old piles of mulch or wood products, in the upper layers of the soil around bedded plants, trees, etc.
Best practices for limiting jumping worms
-
Keep feedstocks and finished compost separate. Incoming leaves, wood chips, yard/garden trimmings that could contain jumping worms, cocoons, or eggs should be kept separate from finished compost and soil products.
Follow BMPs for hot composting. Temperatures of at least 105 F kills jumping worms, cocoons, and eggs. Following BMPs ensures that all the composting material has a chance to heat up.
Ensure that finished compost piles and soil products are not (re)infected. Use separate equipment for handling pre- and post-hot-composting material. Any shared equipment should be thoroughly cleaned before it is moved between areas.
-
Make your own compost. Make sure that your carbon source is clean, which likely means using material from your own site or acquiring wood chips or shavings from clean sources. Avoid leaf mulch sourced from offsite; retain fallen leaves on your property to use for mulch/compost
Buy compost from reputable sources. Recently there have been some reports of snake worms in bags of commercial compost. Even though you may not see any worms in the compost, their egg casings may be present.
If you buy compost in bags, put the bags in the sun for several days to heat up (105F is the temperature that kills jumping worms and cocoons.)
If you buy compost in bulk, solarize the compost by laying it on and wrapping it completely in plastic, which the seems weighted down.
Wash the roots of plants you buy or receive in a plant exchange. Bare root exchanges are best.
Grow plants from seed or cuttings, if you have the time and patience.
Educating yourself and others helps! Ask the recommended questions of your compost facility, landscapers, and garden centers
-
Communicate with homeowners about their knowledge of jumping worms. If they have an infestation, work with them on proper ways to control like mustard treating, handpicking, or solarizing. Report any infestations.
Communicate with soil and plant vendors about how they are mitigating the spread of Jumping Worms
Inspect all plants and soil products for visible worms or castings before transporting them to a new location.
Don’t transport wood products, soil, leaves, or yard debris that is knowingly infested with Jumping Worms.
Purchase bare-root plants if possible
Thoroughly clean equipment, tools, and truck beds between jobs.
-
Communicate with vendors about how they are mitigating the spread of Jumping Worms
Inspect incoming plants and mulch, woodchip, and soil products for visible worms or castings.
Think about solarizing potting soil mixes before transplanting and potting plants.
Sell cuttings or bare-root plants, if possible.
Sterilize re-used pots.
Thoroughly clean garden tools, boots, rakes, shovels, and loader buckets between use.
Utilize impervious areas (concrete, asphalt, etc.) to store soil and plants.
Links to more resources
Snake Worm Invasions - what they are and what home and community composters can do to slow the spread from CAV and Josef Gorres, UVM Dept of Plant & Soil Science
Introduction to Snake Worms & Their Management from Josef Gorres, UVM Dept of Plant & Soil Science
Plant Sale Guidelines to Minimize the Chance of Jumping Worm Spread from UVM Extension
Asian Jumping Worm Fact Sheet for Homeowners from Cornell’s Jumping Worm Outreach, Research, & Management Working Group
Invasive Jumping Worm Frequently Asked Questions from UMass Extension Landscape, Nursery and Urban Forestry Program
Nursery & Landscape Industry Best Management Practices (BMPs) to Reduce the Potential for Spreading Jumping Worms (Amynthas & Metaphire spp.) from Minnesota Nursery & Landscape Association
Best Management Practices for Reducing Risks of Invasive Jumping Worms (Amynthas spp.) in Nurseries from Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection – Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection – Bureau of Plant Industry